Ending: New Puppeteer (Bad)
P accepts the throne, ruling Krat City with an iron hand and invisible strings.
The New Puppeteer ending represents one of the possible conclusions to P’s journey through Krat City, marking a descent into authoritarianism rather than liberation. In this narrative arc, the protagonist accepts the role previously held by Kratios, choosing to maintain order over the city through control and deception instead of restoring hope or freedom to humanity. This outcome serves as a thematic counterpoint to the game’s exploration of truth versus lies. It illustrates how survival often comes at the cost of one's soul, turning P into the very kind of master he set out to defeat. The ending leaves the fate of Krat City ambiguous, safe from monsters but enslaved by a puppeteer who rules from the shadows.
- Subject
- Ending Variation
- Protagonist
- P (The Puppet)
- Location
- Krat City / Puppet Master's Chamber
- Primary Antagonist Defeated
- Kratios
- Unlock Condition
- High Lie Points & Final Choice
- Thematic Focus
- Order through Control
Lore & Background
This ending underscores the central philosophy of the Puppet Master: that humanity is flawed and requires guidance from above. By accepting the position, P validates the idea that lies are necessary tools for stability. The cycle of puppetry continues, suggesting that without self-sacrifice or genuine truth, power merely changes hands rather than being dismantled. The lore implies that Krat City was built upon a foundation of secrets and manipulation. When P takes the chair, he becomes part of this architecture, ensuring the city functions but stripping its citizens of agency. The strings that once bound him now bind others, completing his transformation from victim to ruler.
In Their Own Story
The silence in the chamber is heavy, broken only by the mechanical whirring of gears above. P sits upon the high throne, the cold metal biting through his suit. Below, Krat City glows with artificial light, a sprawling nest of puppets moving without question. He holds the rod that controls them all, feeling the phantom weight of every string connected to his fingers. There is no applause for this victory, only the quiet hum of obedience.
Reader's Guide
Unlocking this conclusion requires a deliberate path of deception throughout the adventure. Players must prioritize lying to non-player characters during dialogue encounters, filling the internal Lie Meter significantly. This accumulation reflects P's willingness to compromise truth for survival or gain. Upon reaching the final confrontation with Kratios in the Puppet Master’s chamber, the options presented depend on this meter. If deceit is high, P can choose to accept the mantle of authority rather than destroy it. Selecting this path cements the New Puppeteer ending. Conversely, maintaining honesty usually restricts access to this dark conclusion or steers the narrative toward liberation. The choice signifies whether order should be enforced through fear and control or earned through trust. This route leaves Krat City safe from monsters but under a tyrannical puppet master who believes he knows best for humanity's sake. This ending emphasizes the cyclical nature of power within the city’s history. By taking the chair, P ensures stability but sacrifices freedom for the people below. The game warns that a lie told once can become a truth lived forever.
Did You Know?
- The Lie Meter is hidden from view during gameplay, requiring players to track their own choices carefully.
- Taking this ending prevents access to the True Ending where P sacrifices himself for the greater good.
- Visual cues in the final cutscene show P wearing Kratios's signature hat or regalia depending on player loadouts.
- This path mirrors the classic Pinocchio tale where becoming human is rejected for remaining a puppet.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the New Puppeteer ending in Lies of P?
This conclusion occurs when P accumulates high Lie Points and chooses to seize power from Kratios instead of freeing humanity. It depicts P accepting the role of Puppet Master, ruling Krat City through deception and strict control rather than offering liberation.
How does P's story end in this variation?
P sits upon the throne as the new ruler, maintaining order over the city with an iron hand while pulling invisible strings to manipulate its inhabitants. The protagonist effectively becomes the tyrant he originally set out to defeat, prioritizing survival at the cost of his own soul.
What specific choices trigger this ending?
Players must consistently make decisions that increase their Lie Points throughout the game and ultimately select the option to take Kratios's place during the final confrontation. This path requires rejecting the chance for truth or freedom in favor of authoritarian stability.
Why is the New Puppeteer outcome considered a 'bad' ending?
It is categorized as negative because P abandons his quest for humanity and hope, instead perpetuating the cycle of oppression that plagued Krat City. The narrative highlights how the pursuit of order through lies corrupts the protagonist into becoming the very evil he fought against.
What thematic role does this ending play in the game?
This arc serves as a dark counterpoint to the themes of truth, illustrating the tragic reality that survival often demands sacrificing one's moral integrity. It reinforces the story's warning that maintaining peace through deception ultimately destroys the spirit of those who enforce it.
More in Narrative Arcs & Endings
Elsewhere in the Lies of P universe
Spotted an error? Know more?
This is a living reference — every entry is fact-audited, and reader corrections feed straight into our audit queue. Suggest an edit · See this site's audit record